A History Of Success In ERISA Claims Matters
Attorney Reagan Toledano

Why can disability benefits end if your health has not improved?

On Behalf of | Nov 12, 2026 | ERISA Long-Term Disability Benefits

Your long-term disability (LTD) benefits may be at risk even if your health has not improved. If you rely on those payments for medical bills and daily expenses, knowing why your insurer might end them can help you prepare for a possible change in your income.

If your disability coverage comes through a private-sector employer, it may fall under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). This federal law covers many workplace disability plans, though most government and church plans are exempt. Your plan’s rules can affect when and why your insurer may stop payments.

Why your insurer may change its decision

Some LTD plans change their rules after a set period, often 24 months. At first, you may qualify because you cannot do your regular job. Later, your insurer may check if you can do other work based on your skills and experience. Some plans also require that the new job pay 60% to 80% of your former income.

Your insurer may also review your medical records and determine that you can work despite ongoing symptoms. For example, you may still have chronic back pain, but your insurer might determine that you can perform less physically demanding work.

What evidence can affect your benefits?

Your insurer may use several types of evidence to decide if you still qualify:

  • Medical records: Whether your records show why you still cannot work.
  • Ability to work: Vocational experts, who assess job demands, may identify work they believe you can do.
  • Medical reviews: The insurer’s medical reviewers may disagree with your doctors about your ability to work.
  • Videos and social media: Insurers may use posts or videos that appear to conflict with your reported health limits.

These findings do not automatically establish that you can return to work.

What if your benefits are terminated?

Under federal ERISA rules, you must receive at least 180 days to appeal after getting a notice that ends your benefits. You can also request relevant claim records at no cost. Courts usually require you to complete the plan’s appeal process before filing a lawsuit.

Why reviewing the termination decision matters

Losing your benefits does not necessarily mean the insurer’s decision is correct. Your policy terms, medical evidence and work limitations may provide grounds to challenge the termination. An attorney experienced in ERISA disability appeals can identify weaknesses in the insurer’s assessment and help you present evidence supporting your continued eligibility.